Initial Thoughts about Black Clover and KONOHANA KITAN

Welcome, all, again.  As we enter a new viewing season, I shall today make a few observations about two new shows that might be getting attention for entirely different reasons.  Mind you, at just one episode in apiece, I’m certainly not attempting any sort of review.  But Black Clover and KONOHANA KITAN have both caught my interest, so I wanted to share a few thoughts. . .

Let us begin with Black Clover, a much-anticipated arrival due to the popularity of its ongoing manga run in Weekly Shonen Jump.  This series had some serious preceding buzz, but sadly it was the buzz-saw voice acting for one of the two protagonists that stole the show.  Lead character Asta, voiced by veteran VA Shun Horie (iDOLM@STER, Whistle!, and others), screams his way through almost the entire first episode, and it gets old very quickly.  Now, we realize that he’s hyper.  And we also realize that he’s frustrated, being the only person around who cannot perform magic.  But none of that excuses what we viewers endured (or tried to).  So now I have to ask: if Horie was searching for Asta’s voice, why didn’t he get better guidance?  Aren’t there a number of production and sound staff present during recording sessions?  This was a big disappointment, especially considering the pretty artwork and solid story: two frenemies who’ve grown up together as church-reared orphans come of age in a land ruled by magic–which only one of them can wield.  Let’s hope that fan complaints (already saturating the internet) can help fix this problem and salvage what should have been an early favorite show!  (I actually liked the show itself, all except for Asta’s grating vocalizations.)

Meanwhile, KONOHANA KITAN–about which I heard barely even a whisper before its sudden appearance–is as muted as Asta is loud.  But, wow!  Oh, wow!  I never knew that pastels could be so vibrant!  Just looking at this show is an experience to be savored–the artwork is exceptional, and often effulgent.  The story seems (superficially, at least) quite similar in plot and setting to Hanasaku Iroha, but in a less-modern age and with a hotel staff of Kitsune.  And that pretty much covers it: cute fox-girls working at a quietly elegant hotel are joined by a new staff member; training and other life experiences ensue.  Soft voices, slow story pacing, and absolutely mesmerizing artwork combine to relax and seduce the viewer.  This show’s first episode was a joy to watch, and I’m already re-watching it.  And, yes, I’m also already planning to purchase the series when it becomes available–it’s just that gorgeous!  So please give this show a chance.  Even if it turns out that it’s not your thing, I doubt that you’ll regret watching.

And that’s it for now.  I’ll probably do another post along these lines before I start trying to actually review any of the new shows–you know, give them time to get up-and-running.  If you want to check out Black Clover, I seriously suggest watching on “mute” with subtitles engaged.  Asta’s constant screeching is that horrendous.  But get good and comfortable for watching KONOHANA KITAN, as you might be in no hurry to leave. . .

Why Call Tanya Evil?

Welcome, all, again.  For my last two reviews, I have explored the serious themes underpinning two very different comedy series.  And so I thought, why not just go ahead and tackle something with a bit more heft?  How about the senselessness and tragedy of war, the hypocrisy of a theological concept of free will, or even the duplicity of deities themselves?  And for a finale, why not briefly explore the concept of evil?  Oh, but this sounds like a boisterous handful, so pull on your tallest boots and get ready to wade deep!  Because this time around we’re discussing Saga of Tanya the Evil.

First, a quick synopsis: Tanya is a petite, blonde girl of European (German) birth who is actually the reincarnated soul of a murdered Japanese salaryman.  She has been born into an alternate world as it staggers into its first World War, about a decade later than did ours.  Because of this later timeline, we witness equipment and tactics reflecting both of our World Wars.  Moreover, magic exists in this world and is readily employed in combat.  And Tanya is just brimming with the stuff!

Magic, however, is not the only thing Tanya carries–in defiance of most concepts of reincarnation with which I am familiar, she is born fully cognizant of her past life.  From her very first conscious thoughts, she is aware of this new dichotomy within her nature.  Now, might this be burden or advantage?  Because such knowledge definitely helps her seem preternaturally  precocious.  But just how much does the arrangement strain her sanity?  Nor does it help that the cause of her strange situation has followed her from life to life, a mysterious deity offended by Tanya’s lack of spiritual faith in both her lives.  It was this being who harangued the doomed salaryman, freezing and prolonging his moment of violent death in order to question and then taunt him about faith, and who then becomes increasingly active in Tanya’s new life despite initially intimating non-interference.   In fact, during his stasis before death, Tanya’s former self had deduced that this interloper was more likely the Devil rather than God.  Unwilling to recognize either as real, however, he designated his tormentor Being X–but it seems the Devil still wants his due.

For while we viewers did not spend much time with Tanya’s former self, we can nonetheless deduce that in her new life she is placed firmly within the parameters of a Judeo/Christian (or Judeo/Christian-like) theology, as witnessed by the wordings of her prayers/spells.  And so her situation gains an immediate familiarity, mirroring Job’s persecution by Satan.  Except, of course, that this time the Devil’s goal is to lead the unwilling to God, rather than drag the faithful away.  OK, you say, that makes no sense at all.  But doesn’t it?  What better revenge for Satan than to make God himself the source of a soul’s torment?  What more elegantly understated way to demand of God: why allow free will if to employ it is to fall from grace?  Why create cognizant creatures, only to punish their self-actualization?  Mind you, I’m not seeking to challenge anyone’s religious beliefs here.  I’m simply pointing out that–from the perspective of a culture not intimately familiar with the historical growth of Christian thought and tradition–it probably all seems a bit convoluted, if not sometimes hypocritical.  And that’s without delving into the traditions that deny free will.

No need.  After all, the suppression and denial of free will are inherent to the military, most especially during the vacuum of war.  Indeed, free will is the antithesis of military order.  To wit, orders are issued; orders are received; orders are executed.  Any variation compromises the mission.  And as a rising star of the [German] Empire’s army, Tanya refuses compromise.  Of course, war is bigger than any one person, and it’s not as if the majority of people actually fighting a war ever had a say in beginning it–which fact itself does nothing to detract from the perceived righteousness of their causes.  But why must ideals be thought so much more valuable than people?  (Don’t look now, but I think you dogma might have rabies. . .)

And that finally brings us to the question of evil.  Why, within the framework of this series, is Tanya called evil?  Is it because she acts in her own best interest?  Don’t we all, occasionally?  Is it because she consistently subjugates compassion to logic?  While that might make her unpleasant company, calling it evil seems to stretch credibility.  Perhaps, then, because she is so ruthless in battle?  This sounds more likely, especially when we consider the long shadows cast by such figures as Genghis Khan or Attila the Hun.  Or is it ultimately because she denies not just God’s grace, but his very existence?  Certainly the nuns who taught me catechism in my youth considered atheism the epitome of evil.  But at seven episodes in, I still can’t offer a satisfactory answer.  Self-serving, unfeeling, likely psychopathic, and even somewhat depraved all aptly describe Tanya; I’ve thus far seen nothing to indicate evil as I interpret the word, meaning to deliberately cause unnecessary pain or destruction.  Or might the evil within the title really be one of those “lost-in-translation” situations?

I like this show.  A lot.  It’s brave, relatively fast-paced, and exhibits a gallows humor all too rare in the shows I’ve seen lately.  And while admittedly dark, with grim themes, it is beautifully drawn and animated (despite the frequent use of CGI).  So sit down and make yourself comfortable–you won’t stay so for long, I promise.

Addendum (03 March, 2017–Per Episode 8):

And no sooner do I post the above review than an episode arrives that presents Tanya seeming to make unconscionable decisions regarding what we now call urban warfare.  She is ordered to engage and destroy enemy forces within a formerly captured city, then informed that all civilians remaining after an ordered evacuation will legally be considered enemy combatants.  To wit, she is being ordered to kill civilians.  To be fair, native militia and armed partisans are organic to occupations–and they are most certainly combatants!  Engaging them is simple–if brutal–reality.  That they melt into and hide within civilian populations is also factual.  This means that engaging them almost assures some amount of collateral damage.  It should be remembered, however, that these actors come to the occupiers’ attention only through their own efforts; they signal their presence through their actions.  Put bluntly, they initiate others’ efforts to destroy them.  And it is their disappearance into the larger civilian population that immediately endangers those civilians.

I would next point out something that might have easily been overlooked, the fact that Tanya challenged the initial order by tossing it right back to her commanding officer.  In the military, when you receive an order, you execute that order.  Tanya instead repeated it, with commentary, back to the superior who had issued it.  This was clearly a challenge to its content.  Admittedly, the issue is muddied by the late revelation of a paper she had previously submitted concerning the legalities of engaging civilian populaces.  Was the paper a nod to the reality of engaging civilians, while her challenge represented her true opinion?  Or was that challenge simply to camouflage her own embrace of the tenets of total warfare?  Either way, the fact that she issued the challenge is undeniable.

Dresden, 1945

Last, I would caution against anyone getting comfortable on what they might consider moral high ground.  Tanya is, after all, from our own world.  And in our world, civilians have almost always been targeted during war, and by all sides of a conflict.  After all, it is civilians who supply their army; eradicate the civilians and their army starves.  Or freezes.  Or finds some other uncomfortable way to die.  Consider World War II: as to hiding behind legalities, did Japan really think that declaring war minutes before the bombs fell on Pearl Harbor would negate its being a surprise attack?  That was, after all, their plan.  And as for targeting civilians, did the US really think that it was destroying important military targets by firebombing huge swaths of residential Tokyo?  In both cases, the larger target was the enemy’s morale.  So let’s rain rockets onto London!  And let’s burn Dresden to the ground!  Let’s crush enemy morale through indiscriminate slaughter!  If Tanya is truly walking this path, might it not be simply because she realizes its inevitability?  To willingly employ a tactic does offer at least the possibility of controlling both its progression and its outcome.  And while this latest episode might indeed finally signal Tanya’s descent into evil, I still have hope for her.  After all, she’s still true enough to herself to fight against divine intervention in her life. . .and that might yet prove a strength beyond the reach of any external power.





Revisiting Flying Witch

Welcome, all, again.  Flying Witch is a leisurely slice-of-life offering which was simulcast on Crunchyroll earlier this spring and summer (2016).  Its titular heroine is Makoto Kowata, a teenage girl of magical lineage who moves away from home to train.  Well, almost away from home.  Like her older sister Akane before her, Mako-chan moves in with cousins living in Aomori, a rural community.  This branch of the family, the Kuramoto(s), have no magic but are quite accustomed to its possession and use by their kinfolk, making them the perfect support network for a young witch-in-training.  (Poor Kiki only wished she had it so good!  Still, a beautiful continuity of theme from Kiki’s Delivery Service.)  It also helps that Makoto used to regularly visit the Kuramoto family years ago when Akane lived with them, making her own stay more like a homecoming.  Oh, and that her cousin Kei Kuramoto is Makoto’s own age and used to play with her during those visits.  So despite her move, Mako-chan is home again.


But Makoto was never very good with directions, and things have a tendency towards change.  Taken together, these two facts can make even the most welcoming environment assume certain challenging aspects.  Upon arriving in Aomori, Makoto isn’t even sure how to find her relatives’ house; she certainly isn’t prepared for the inquisitiveness of Kei’s younger sister Chinatsu, who is unfamiliar with the Kowata side of the family.  Chinatsu’s deadpan responses to the changes in her little world are gems of humor!  But although almost severely skeptical at first, she becomes enamored of the new experiences and characters revealed to her by her older cousin.  And once Akane starts stopping by to check on Makoto–then begins extending those visits–Chinatsu wastes no time apprenticing herself to the more (the moe?) experienced witch!  After all, not all witches are born so; thus, it looks as if the Kuramoto clan will finally have a witch of their own, and with the full moral support of her parents and brother.


And that pretty much sums up the essence of this series.  You’ll probably notice that I placed very little emphasis on witchcraft and magic.  Frankly, that’s because this show isn’t so much about witchcraft and magic, but about a family–in this case, an extended family–providing its members with love and support in which to root themselves as they become the people they wish to be.  These are not perfect people: they make mistakes; they get in each others’ way.  But they accept that about themselves and each other.  If I were to compare Flying Witch to just one other show, it would be Non Non Biyori–and that’s a high compliment!  A young female student from the city moves to a rural area and proceeds to establish herself within the community, making friends and learning about local life.  Both series have a certain quietude about them, and both focus upon the close bonds of family and friendship.  (Meanwhile, Chinatsu and Ren-chon share an understated deadpan delivery that packs a wallop, and a certain amount of pampered indulgence from the the older members of their respective groups.)  Magic is inherent to this story, but it is not the story.  And Flying Witch is a better show because of that.